The Bootcamp – Biggest Loser – Infomercial Effect
Filed Under: Fat Loss · Fit Over 40
Filed Under: Fat Loss · Fit Over 40
Regardless of your opinion on these, they are going to keep physical therapists busier over the coming years.
There is definitely a positive effect of these various programs – getting people to exercise more intensely. There is also a negative aspect to this growing phenomena – getting people to exercise more intensely.
Many research studies in the last decade have shown proof that intense exercise, particularly various forms of interval training, cardio strength training, getting more work done in a shorter amount of time, can keep the metabolism elevated for several hours after the workout and burn lots of calories.
Therein lies the rub, with the increased popularity of these programs comes the increased risk of injury, IF simple progressions are not followed.
The key to doing successful resistance training is to LOGICALLY follow a progressive method of increasing resistance – GRADUALLY increase the amount of weight/resistance, the amount of sets and/or repetitions…..
making sure that the individual is prepared for the training for that session. I recently heard of a woman who had come in to physical therapy for elbow pain. She had completed 120 pushups in her exercise class.
I’ve seen this woman and she is in incredible shape for a 50 year old. She can probably run circles around many college age women….but unless she GRADUALLY built up to doing this number of pushups, no matter what kind of shape she is in, she will likely get injured…..and she did.
One of my clients told me of a friend of hers injured her knee recently in an exercise class doing 180’s – this lady is 61 years old and the only 180 exercise I’m familiar with is a 180 degree jump, which can be seen in a popular infomercial promoting a home fat loss program.
I asked my client if her friend is in really good shape and she said she wasn’t. Many of my 50 something clients have had a past injury or two or three, making jump training something where the risk is not worth the rewards.
You might make the argument that people over 60 lose not just muscle strength and mass with aging, but also have a reduced amount of muscle power which is related to how quickly a muscle can generate force. How quickly a muscle generates force can make the difference between falling and not falling.
Obviously, falling is not good. So while I believe that there is always an exception to the rule, I don’t have any of my clients that age doing jump training. Kettlebell swings are a much better way to generate muscle power without the joint forces and twisting of 180’s.
Last week I was having lunch at a local grocery store when a woman approached a couple sitting at a table near mine. When one woman said something about boot camp class I tried to listen in without being obvious.
One of the women said something about her knees bothering her and going to physical therapy or needing surgery or something to that effect. Upon leaving, she told the other woman that she hopes her back starts feeling better?!?
Am I making my point clear yet!! All of these events happened within a period of ONE WEEK in Iowa.
So yes, while the best benefits happen when you push your body out of its comfort zone, make sure that you are READY for that level of intensity and you GRADUALLY built up to that point.
By the way, having a 430 pound individual run on a treadmill…to the point where he couldn’t keep up and fell on his knee, luckily not injuring it….is NOT a good idea!
Train hard but make sure to train smart, also.
Get moving!
Brian Morgan